Best Personal Injury Lawyers in Vermont

Choosing the right personal injury lawyer in Vermont is crucial for your case's success. This page reviews 13 top attorneys and law firms, helping you make an informed decision.

13 attorneys reviewedVermont
1
Gravel & Shea PCPersonal Injury

Burlington, VT

Client-FocusedDetail-OrientedAffordable

Gravel & Shea PC, located in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in personal injury law, providing seasoned legal expertise and a client-centered approach to case management. The firm's seasoned attorneys are known for their strong negotiation skills, which often result in favorable settlements without the need for prolonged court battles. With a focus on addressing the comprehensive needs of their clients, Gravel & Shea PC distinguishes itself through personalized legal strategies designed to maximize compensation.

Best For

Best for clients seeking experienced negotiators for complex personal injury claims.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for the lowest contingency fees.

Strengths

  • +Experienced attorneys with a track record of favorable settlements, setting them apart from newer practices like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • +Client-focused approach ensures personalized service, a contrast to larger firms such as Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Strong negotiation skills that often prevent the need for costly and lengthy trials, unlike practices with less seasoned negotiators.

Trade-offs

  • Higher contingency fees compared to budget-focused firms like Winburn Law Offices.
  • May not offer as broad a range of legal services as multi-specialty firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.
2

Burlington, VT

Well-KnownHighly ReviewedAffordable

Shillen Mackall & Seldon, based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in handling personal injury cases with a focus on severe injury and wrongful death claims. Their approach combines deep legal knowledge with a personalized strategy tailored to each client's unique situation, ensuring strong advocacy and thorough representation. Distinctively, they prioritize direct attorney involvement in each case, setting them apart in a field where clients often deal with assistants or paralegals.

Best For

Best for clients seeking experienced legal representation in severe injury and wrongful death cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients seeking low-cost legal services or those with minor injury claims.

Strengths

  • +Compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC, Shillen Mackall & Seldon offers more personalized attention with direct attorney involvement.
  • +Focuses exclusively on personal injury, providing depth of expertise not found in more generalist firms such as Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Known for a tailored legal approach, adapting strategies to the specifics of each case, unlike more standardized service models seen in larger practices.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller size may limit resources compared to multidisciplinary firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • Lack of multiple practice areas may not suit clients needing diverse legal services beyond personal injury.
3
Maley and Maley, PLLCPersonal Injury

Burlington, VT

Well-KnownLocal FavoriteAffordable

Maley and Maley, PLLC, based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes exclusively in personal injury law, focusing on cases that include accidents, negligence, and wrongful death. The firm distinguishes itself through a client-centered approach, ensuring personalized attention and tailored legal strategies. With thorough case evaluations and a depth of experience, Maley and Maley stands out for its dedication to securing favorable outcomes for its clients.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking personalized legal representation in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for legal services outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +More focused practice on personal injury compared to broader practice areas at firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Client-centered approach ensures more personalized service than larger firms such as Gravel & Shea PC
  • +Specializes in thorough case evaluations, potentially offering more detailed insights than generalist firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP

Trade-offs

  • Smaller scope of practice compared to multi-disciplinary firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • May have fewer resources than larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
4

Burlington, VT

ResponsiveAccessibleAffordable

Paul Frank + Collins P.C. specializes in personal injury law, with a focus on cases involving accidents, negligence, and wrongful death in Burlington, Vermont. Their legal team is known for a client-focused approach, ensuring personalized service and dedicated advocacy. The firm stands out due to its seasoned negotiators and strategists who prioritize optimal outcomes over quick settlements.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking experienced negotiators for complex personal injury claims.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for those requiring legal services outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +Stronger negotiation skills compared to local peers like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP, leading to potentially better settlement terms
  • +Client-focused approach ensures personalized case handling, distinguishing them from larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
  • +Experienced legal team capable of managing intricate personal injury cases which might overwhelm smaller practices like Maley and Maley, PLLC

Trade-offs

  • Less broad legal expertise compared to multi-specialty firms like Gravel & Shea PC
  • Smaller size might limit resources compared to larger firms like Winburn Law Offices
5

Montpelier, VT

Well-KnownLocal FavoriteMid-Range

Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP specializes in personal injury law, focusing on cases involving accidents, medical malpractice, and negligence in Montpelier, Vermont. The firm adopts a client-centered approach, emphasizing strong communication and a personalized legal strategy tailored to each client's unique situation. Their experienced team ensures thorough representation and advocacy, distinguishing them within Vermont's legal landscape.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking personalized legal strategies in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost, quick settlement options.

Strengths

  • +Client-centered approach contrasts with Gravel & Shea PC's broader legal scope, offering more personalized attention in personal injury cases.
  • +Strong emphasis on communication, ensuring that clients are well-informed compared to larger firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Experienced team dedicated solely to personal injury, providing more specialized knowledge than generalist firms such as Winburn Law Offices.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller team size compared to firms like Gravel & Shea PC, which may limit resources for extremely complex cases.
  • Focus strictly on personal injury might not cater to clients needing integrated legal services beyond personal injury.
6
Winburn Law OfficesPersonal Injury

Bennington, VT

ResponsiveClient-FocusedAffordable

Winburn Law Offices in Bennington, Vermont, specializes exclusively in personal injury law, advocating for clients injured due to accidents, negligence, or wrongful acts. The firm is distinguished by its client-focused approach, ensuring personalized legal representation and strong client-lawyer communication. Their experienced attorneys excel in negotiating favorable outcomes, leveraging deep local legal knowledge.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking experienced, personalized legal representation in personal injury cases in Vermont.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for nationwide legal representation or those needing services outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +Strong focus on personal injury law offers a depth of knowledge and expertise not found in more generalist firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Client-focused approach ensures personalized service and direct communication, setting them apart from larger firms such as Gravel & Shea PC.
  • +Proven negotiation skills that often result in favorable settlements without the need for prolonged court trials, unlike broader practices such as Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP

Trade-offs

  • Limited to personal injury law, which might not suit those needing more comprehensive legal services compared to full-service firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • Primarily serves the Vermont area, potentially less ideal for clients requiring representation across multiple states unlike Maley and Maley, PLLC.
7

Burlington, VT

AccessibleExperiencedFree Consultation

Martin Delaney & Ricci Law Group specializes in personal injury law, offering dedicated representation to clients in Burlington, Vermont. They focus on cases involving accidents, negligence, and injuries, ensuring thorough legal support and strong client advocacy. Their approach combines extensive legal knowledge with strategic negotiation skills to secure favorable outcomes for their clients.

Best For

Best for clients seeking personalized and assertive legal representation in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for legal services outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +Client-focused representation ensures personalized legal strategies, setting them apart from larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC.
  • +Strong negotiation skills lead to favorable settlements without the need for prolonged court cases, distinguishing them from firms with a more litigious approach like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • +In-depth knowledge of personal injury law in Vermont provides clients with a nuanced understanding of local legal intricacies, compared to broader regional firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller team may lead to longer case handling times compared to larger firms such as Maley and Maley, PLLC.
  • Focused primarily on personal injury, which may limit the scope of advice for clients with multifaceted legal needs, unlike full-service firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.
8
Rich Cassidy LawPersonal Injury

Burlington, VT

ExperiencedEstablished PracticePremium

Rich Cassidy Law, based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in personal injury law, focusing on clients who have suffered due to others' negligence. The firm is noted for its client-centered approach, ensuring personalized and direct communication throughout the legal process. Rich Cassidy's extensive experience and strong negotiation skills set them apart, aiming for the most favorable outcomes for their clients.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking personalized legal representation in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for large, multi-practice area law firms.

Strengths

  • +Client-focused approach provides more personalized service compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC and Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Strong negotiation skills enhance the likelihood of favorable settlements, standing out from firms without dedicated personal injury focus.
  • +Rich Cassidy's extensive personal injury law experience offers deep insights and strategies not as prevalent in more generalist firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller size may limit resources compared to larger firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • Focused practice area means less versatility in handling cases outside of personal injury compared to full-service firms like Maley and Maley, PLLC.
9
Plante & Hanley, P.C.Personal Injury

White River Junction, VT

Local FavoriteAccessibleAffordable

Plante & Hanley, P.C. is a personal injury law firm based in White River Junction, Vermont, dedicated to representing clients who have suffered due to others' negligence. They focus on securing comprehensive compensations for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering, employing a client-centered approach that prioritizes personalized legal strategies. Their experienced attorneys stand out with robust negotiation skills, ensuring that each case is poised for the best possible outcome.

Best For

Best for clients seeking experienced negotiators for complex personal injury claims.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for legal representation outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +Stronger focus on personal injury compared to broader practices like Paul Frank + Collins P.C., which handles a variety of legal areas
  • +Client-focused approach ensures personalized case handling, setting them apart from larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
  • +Experienced in deep negotiations which may yield better settlements than less specialized firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP

Trade-offs

  • Smaller scope of practice compared to multi-disciplinary firms like Gravel & Shea PC
  • May have fewer resources than larger firms like Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
10
Shoup Evers & GreenPersonal Injury

Burlington, VT

Highly ReviewedAccessibleMid-Range

Shoup Evers & Green specializes in personal injury law, providing dedicated advocacy and tailored legal solutions from their Burlington, Vermont office. Their approach combines personalized client service with deep expertise in a range of personal injury claims, from auto accidents to wrongful death cases. The firm's commitment to individual client needs sets them apart, ensuring thorough and compassionate representation.

Best For

Best for clients seeking personalized and compassionate legal representation in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for the lowest contingency fees or bulk case handling.

Strengths

  • +Strong personalized client advocacy provides a more tailored approach compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC.
  • +Focused expertise in personal injury law, unlike broader practices such as Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Develops customized legal strategies for each case, which may offer advantages over firms with a more standardized approach like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller team size may limit resource availability compared to larger firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • Might not offer as broad a network of expert witnesses as multi-practice firms like Maley and Maley, PLLC.
11

Burlington, VT

Highly ReviewedWell-KnownAffordable

Lynn, Lynn, Blackman & Manitsky, P.C. specializes in personal injury law, offering dedicated legal representation in Burlington, Vermont. This firm distinguishes itself with a client-focused approach, ensuring personalized and thorough attention for each case. They combine extensive legal knowledge with strong negotiation skills to advocate effectively for their clients.

Best For

Best for clients seeking personalized and attentive legal representation in personal injury cases.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost or quick settlement-focused legal services.

Strengths

  • +Offers more personalized client service compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC and Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Possesses a deep focus on personal injury law, which may provide an edge over general practice firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
  • +Strong negotiation skills that can lead to better outcomes in complex cases, setting them apart from firms with a more transactional approach.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller team may lead to longer case handling times compared to larger firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.
  • May have fewer resources than larger, multi-specialty firms such as Maley and Maley, PLLC, potentially impacting very complex cases.
12
Behrens VenmanPersonal Injury

Burlington, VT

Client-FocusedFeaturedMid-Range

Behrens Venman, located in Burlington, Vermont, focuses exclusively on Personal Injury law, providing dedicated advocacy for those injured due to others' negligence. The firm is distinguished by its personalized client attention, ensuring each case is handled with unique strategizing and empathetic client support. Their in-depth knowledge of Vermont law and superior negotiation skills empower clients to secure fitting compensation for their injuries and losses.

Best For

Best for clients seeking personalized attention and expert negotiation in personal injury claims.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for legal representation in areas outside of personal injury law.

Strengths

  • +Offers more personalized client attention compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC and Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Strong negotiation skills that frequently result in favorable settlements without the need for prolonged litigation.
  • +Deep expertise in Vermont-specific personal injury law, providing an edge over non-local firms.

Trade-offs

  • Smaller firm size may limit resources compared to larger counterparts like Maley and Maley, PLLC or Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.
  • Focused exclusively on personal injury, potentially less versatile than multi-practice firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon.
13

Burlington, VT

Local FavoriteExperiencedAffordable

Sheehey Furlong & Behm P.C. specializes in personal injury law, focusing on a client-centered approach to legal representation in Burlington, Vermont. The firm's experienced legal team prioritizes strong advocacy for victims' rights, seeking to secure just compensation for those affected by accidents and negligence. Their approach is tailored to the unique circumstances of each case, ensuring personalized legal strategies.

Best For

Best for individuals seeking experienced personal injury representation with a strong emphasis on client advocacy.

May Not Suit

May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost legal solutions or those outside of the personal injury domain.

Strengths

  • +Stronger client-centered approach compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC, emphasizing personalized legal strategies.
  • +Dedicated focus on personal injury provides deeper expertise than general practice firms such as Paul Frank + Collins P.C.
  • +Highly experienced in advocating for victims' rights, potentially leading to more favorable outcomes than newer firms like Maley and Maley, PLLC.

Trade-offs

  • Might be more expensive compared to smaller specialized firms like Shillen Mackall & Seldon due to a broader team of experienced attorneys.
  • Fewer locations and potentially less flexibility in meeting places compared to larger firms like Biggam Fox Skinner, LLP.

How We Rank

Attorneys listed here are sourced from multiple professional directories including BestLawyers.com and Justia.

Our editorial rankings consider directory presence, practice area specialization, geographic coverage, and available client feedback.

Rankings are editorial in nature and do not constitute an endorsement. We encourage you to verify all credentials with your state bar association.

What to Look For

When choosing a personal injury lawyer in Vermont, consider their experience and specialization in your type of injury. Effective communication and clear fee structures are important. Review their track record to assess how successfully they have resolved similar cases.

Key Takeaways

Selecting the right personal injury attorney involves assessing their experience, specialization, and success rate. Ensure they offer transparent communication and understand their fee structure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Resources

Talk to a Qualified Attorney

Fill out this form and we'll connect you with experienced lawyers in your area.

No spam. Your information is secure and confidential.

Are You a Lawyer or Law Firm?

Get listed on BestLawyersReviews and connect with potential clients in your area.

Rankings and editorial scores are based on publicly available information including directory data, practice focus, and experience indicators. This is not legal advice. Please verify all details directly with attorneys before making hiring decisions.

Last updated: March 31, 2026