Best Criminal Defense Lawyers in Vermont
Selecting the right criminal defense lawyer in Vermont is crucial for navigating legal challenges effectively. This page reviews 9 top attorneys and law firms, providing insights to help you make an informed choice.
Bothfeld & Volk, P.C., based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in criminal defense across a spectrum of charges, from minor misdemeanors to serious felonies. Their approach to client service is personalized, ensuring that each case is handled with unique strategic defense strategies tailored to the client's specific situation. This client-focused approach, combined with seasoned legal expertise, sets them apart in a crowded field.
Best For
Best for individuals facing serious felony charges who value a personalized defense strategy.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for those seeking low-cost legal services or quick plea deals.
Strengths
- +Tailored defense strategies that adapt to the complexity of serious felonies, unlike broader approaches seen at firms like Kaplan and Kaplan.
- +Direct involvement of senior attorneys in every case, offering a level of expertise not always available at larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC.
- +Deep local judicial system knowledge, providing an edge over non-local firms such as Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C.
Trade-offs
- –Potentially higher costs compared to budget-focused firms like Law Offices of John B. St. Francis.
- –Less capacity for handling extremely high volumes of cases simultaneously compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC.
Kaplan and Kaplan, located in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in criminal defense, providing expert legal representation with a focus on individual rights and personalized legal strategies. They excel in crafting unique defenses based on the nuanced details of each case, distinguishing them from many peers in the Burlington area. Their attorneys utilize their extensive knowledge of criminal law to advocate strongly for their clients throughout the legal process.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking aggressive defense strategies tailored to their specific legal circumstances.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost legal solutions or minor legal consultations.
Strengths
- +Offers more personalized legal strategies compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- +Strong focus on client advocacy, ensuring thorough representation in and out of court
- +Specific expertise in a range of criminal law areas, which provides a depth of knowledge not always found at general practice firms like Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C.
Trade-offs
- –Smaller firm size may limit resources compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- –Focus exclusively on criminal law might not provide as broad a perspective as multi-disciplinary firms like Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
Jason J. Sawyer, Attorney and Counselor at Law, specializes in criminal defense in Burlington, Vermont. With a sharp focus on criminal law, Jason offers personalized attention to each client, ensuring a tailored defense strategy. His strengths in negotiation set him apart, allowing for effective resolutions often outside the courtroom.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking experienced, personalized criminal defense in Vermont.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost, quick legal representation.
Strengths
- +Compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC, Jason provides more personalized attention due to his focused practice size.
- +Strong negotiation skills that often result in favorable plea deals, setting him apart from firms with a less strategic approach.
- +Deep experience in criminal law specifically, unlike general practice attorneys at Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C.
Trade-offs
- –Smaller practice size compared to firms like Gravel & Shea PC may limit resources for very complex or high-profile cases.
- –Focused exclusively on criminal law which might not suit clients needing additional legal services outside this sphere.
Law Offices of John B. St. Francis in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in criminal defense, handling cases from misdemeanors to serious felonies. The firm stands out for its singular focus on criminal law, providing strong client advocacy and a deep understanding of legal processes. Their approach is tailored to navigate complex legal challenges effectively, ensuring detailed attention to each case.
Best For
Best for individuals facing serious felony charges who need focused criminal law expertise.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients seeking legal assistance outside of criminal law.
Strengths
- +Focused exclusively on criminal law, unlike general practice firms like Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C.
- +Strong client advocacy, providing more personalized representation compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- +Deep understanding of both state and federal criminal laws, which is more specialized compared to broader practices such as Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
Trade-offs
- –Limited to criminal law, less versatile compared to full-service firms like Kaplan and Kaplan
- –Smaller team may mean fewer resources compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
Gravel & Shea PC in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in criminal defense, offering skilled legal representation across a range of criminal matters including misdemeanors, felonies, and DUI charges. Their approach combines personalized legal strategies with aggressive advocacy, ensuring each client's rights are vigorously protected. The firm stands out for its seasoned attorneys who bring deep local legal insights and a tailored approach to each case.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking experienced, personalized criminal defense in Vermont.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients seeking low-cost legal solutions or those outside the Vermont jurisdiction.
Strengths
- +Strong local legal expertise compared to newer firms like Kaplan and Kaplan
- +Personalized legal representation ensures tailored defense strategies, setting them apart from larger, less personalized firms
- +Proven track record in handling complex criminal cases, offering a more experienced perspective than smaller practices like Jason J. Sawyer, Attorney and Counselor at Law
Trade-offs
- –Higher costs compared to budget firms like Law Offices of John B. St. Francis
- –Limited to criminal law, unlike multi-disciplinary firms such as Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C.
Montroll, Backus & Oettinger, P.C., based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in criminal defense, providing seasoned legal advocacy to those accused of criminal activities. They stand out for their deep understanding of criminal law nuances and a commitment to crafting personalized defense strategies. The firm emphasizes individual attention to ensure that every client's case is meticulously prepared and robustly represented in court.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking experienced and personalized criminal defense representation in Vermont.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost legal services or those needing legal assistance outside of criminal law.
Strengths
- +Compared to broader practices like Gravel & Shea PC, Montroll, Backus & Oettinger focuses exclusively on criminal law, providing them with a specialized edge.
- +Unlike larger firms such as Kaplan and Kaplan, this firm offers more personalized and attentive service to each client.
- +Their attorneys have a reputation for meticulous case preparation, which can be a differentiator from firms with higher caseloads like Law Offices of John B. St. Francis.
Trade-offs
- –While providing highly personalized service, their smaller team size may limit the speed of case handling compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC.
- –Their focused expertise in criminal law means they might not offer the breadth of services found at multi-disciplinary firms like Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
Burke Law, based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes in defending a wide range of criminal charges with a strong focus on expert knowledge of criminal law and robust client advocacy. The firm is distinguished by its tailored legal strategies designed to meet individual client needs, ensuring thorough representation in Vermont's unique legal environment.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking personalized defense strategies in criminal law.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for clients looking for low-cost, high-volume legal representation.
Strengths
- +Offers more personalized legal strategies compared to the larger practices like Gravel & Shea PC
- +Strong client advocacy provides a competitive edge over firms with a broader practice focus such as Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
- +Deep expertise in Vermont criminal law not matched by general practice firms like Kaplan and Kaplan
Trade-offs
- –Smaller firm size may limit resources compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- –Focus on criminal law might not cater to clients needing associated civil litigation services
Handy Law, based in Burlington, Vermont, specializes exclusively in criminal defense. The firm crafts personalized defense strategies tailored to each client's unique situation, backed by extensive experience in handling everything from minor misdemeanors to major felonies. Their in-depth understanding of Vermont's criminal law system and commitment to client advocacy sets them apart.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking vigorous defense in complex felony cases.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for those requiring legal assistance outside of criminal law.
Strengths
- +Offers more personalized defense strategies compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- +Focuses solely on criminal law, providing deeper expertise than general practice firms like Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
- +Direct involvement in each case, unlike broader practices such as Kaplan and Kaplan where multiple practice areas may dilute focus
Trade-offs
- –Smaller scope of practice compared to multi-disciplinary firms like Gravel & Shea PC, limiting resources for cases that intersect with other legal areas
- –May not have as wide a network as larger, more diverse firms like Law Offices of John B. St. Francis
Sheehey Furlong & Behm P.C. specializes in criminal defense, providing rigorous legal representation with a deep understanding of criminal law nuances in Burlington, Vermont. Their client-centered approach prioritizes personalized strategies tailored to the specifics of each case, ensuring that clients' rights and interests are robustly defended.
Best For
Best for individuals seeking experienced, tailored defense strategies in complex criminal cases.
May Not Suit
May not be the best fit for those seeking low-cost legal services or quick legal resolutions.
Strengths
- +More personalized case handling compared to larger firms like Gravel & Shea PC
- +Focus solely on criminal law, unlike Kaplan and Kaplan, which handles multiple practice areas
- +Strong local presence and deep understanding of Vermont's criminal justice system, potentially more localized expertise than firms like Bothfeld & Volk, P.C.
Trade-offs
- –Potentially higher cost compared to smaller, single-attorney practices like Jason J. Sawyer, Attorney and Counselor at Law
- –Lesser focus on digital engagement and online resources compared to competitors like Law Offices of John B. St. Francis
How We Rank
Attorneys listed here are sourced from multiple professional directories including BestLawyers.com and Justia.
Our editorial rankings consider directory presence, practice area specialization, geographic coverage, and available client feedback.
Rankings are editorial in nature and do not constitute an endorsement. We encourage you to verify all credentials with your state bar association.
What to Look For
When choosing a criminal defense lawyer in Vermont, consider their experience in similar cases, specialization in relevant areas of law, and their communication style. Evaluate their fee structure and track record. Effective communication and a clear understanding of fees are key to establishing a successful attorney-client relationship.
Key Takeaways
Selecting the right criminal defense attorney involves reviewing their experience, understanding their fee structure, and ensuring they specialize in the relevant area of law. Effective communication is fundamental for a successful defense.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Resources
Talk to a Qualified Attorney
Fill out this form and we'll connect you with experienced lawyers in your area.
Are You a Lawyer or Law Firm?
Get listed on BestLawyersReviews and connect with potential clients in your area.
Rankings and editorial scores are based on publicly available information including directory data, practice focus, and experience indicators. This is not legal advice. Please verify all details directly with attorneys before making hiring decisions.
Last updated: March 31, 2026